Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clark Coleman's avatar

In my study of hermeneutics in the Restoration Movement, I got into a lot of details. Then one day I realized that all of the formulas (e.g. CENI: Command, Example, Necessary Inference) only accounted for about half of our real hermeneutics.

The other half is the guilt-by-association hermeneutic. If a denomination does it, we are not allowed to do it. So much for our freedom in Christ.

I also observe that those who say "We can celebrate the birth of Christ at any time during the year" never do so. They don't lead "Hark! The Herald Angels Sing" in June. They talk about how they could do so if they wished, and how it does not have to be sung in December, but it never happens. I led it two days ago (well, the first verse as an opener, anyway).

Expand full comment
John Ellwood's avatar

I for one, am glad that the congregation I attend does not celebrate the Christmas holiday during worship. Many observe the holiday, but it isn't a part of worship services. If the tradition existed during the first century with the Apostles it would be a no brainer. There are pagan influences mixed in with this holiday as well as with Easter. Just seems to me to be one of those doors you don't want to open. I did lead Joy to the World just after Thanksgiving though...it is a great song, and could be sung at anytime throughout the year, and should be.

On Unity - I am all for Unity though and wouldn't object to some congregations observing this, or some other day they deem "special". Hopefully, I am the stronger brother, but I would be wary of what other influences brought into worship that might be introduced as a result that are not described in scripture. As always, I appreciate your perspectives, and the discussion on various matters, especially on matters of unity.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts