How to Know When Your Love of Sports has Become Idolatry

A good thing taken too far

For most of my life it’s been rare to meet someone who is a bigger sports fan than me. As a kid, I played what must have been thousands of hours of hockey and joined in basketball, football, and baseball games every chance I got.

Once I outgrew the competing phase of my life, the consuming phase took up an even bigger portion of my time. I’m one of those guys who could recount decades of Super Bowl, World Series, NBA Finals, and Stanley Cup Finals champions, could name all the stadiums and coaches and even mascots, could recite stats from years ago in numerous sports, etc.

Between getting married and the birth of our four children, the time required to be that invested has rapidly faded. But, I’m still a general sports fan and a die hard follower of a couple of teams.

I give all that context to say two things: 1) I don’t think it’s wrong at all for Christians to enjoy sports, and 2) I’m acutely aware of what it looks like to make an idol out of sports.

I want to offer to fellow Christian sports fans a few words of caution about three areas of your life that can be consumed by the idolatry of sports.

1. YOUR TIME

Of course, there’s the one I’m sure you’re expecting an article like this to cover – missing worship for sports. And that expectation is valid, because it’s a needed critique. Churches all over America see membership drop as certain youth sports seasons start up. Some members will skip any time their team has a big game that overlaps with worship. I will always be grateful that my parents took a firm stand on this. 

“But my kid is really good! They could get a scholarship or go pro!” First of all, maaaaaaybe. Maybe. The odds are incredibly long. But secondly, that’s not the point at all, really. There is no number of Super Bowl rings at which one can say, “Yeah, that was worth more than a devout walk with God.”

As Jesus asked, “For what will it profit a man if he gains the whole world, and loses his own soul? Or what will a man give in exchange for his soul?” And while their odds to get to the big show are pretty small, there’s a 100% chance they will stand before God at the judgment. Choose wisely in how you prepare them for the future.

“But it’s only three or four Sundays a year!” It might be a small percentage of the Sundays. But it’s 100% of the Sundays in which there’s a conflict. If every time God goes up against sports He loses out, your kids will get the message. What a low view of God it would take to think we can withhold what we owe Him for some silly games.

However, it’s not just about Sunday attendance. Plenty of Christians will tell you they struggle to find time for Bible study and prayer while also being able to give a recap of every big play from their team’s three hour bowl game and reciting the lineups to their 4 fantasy football teams.

God has blessed us with hobbies and leisure activities, and the time to enjoy them, but they need to be kept in their right and natural place. Only after the higher obligations to God, family, and work have been met can we find the time to enjoy hobbies properly.

2. YOUR MENTAL ENERGY

This one largely overflows from the last – where we put our time is generally where we’re going to put our focus.

• If you’re at worship while the game’s on but can’t resist the pull to check your phone to see the score, it might be time to reconsider some things.

• If there’s a family event—a loved one’s birthday, a child’s sporting event or extracurricular activity, an anniversary, or the like—and you spend the whole time trying to find a way to watch the game, it might be time to reconsider some things.

• If you can speak at length about all the sports analysis you’ve taken in through talk shows and podcasts all week but can’t carry on a 2 minute conversation about the contents of that week’s sermon, it may be time to reconsider some things.

These kinds of tests reveal the bandwidth we’re dedicating to our different interests. It’s in these manifestations that we can see what we really care about. If I spend more time thinking about and talking about my teams than I do my relationships with God, my wife, and my kids, the priorities are out of line. “No other gods before me” (Exodus 20:3) can include the hobbies we love, too.

And everybody around me will see it. My wife and kids will know if sports matter to me more than they do, or if sports are a bigger priority in our home than God. If I take a huge interest in their athletics but don’t have much involvement when it comes to their spiritual lives, it will send a message loud and clear.

The kind of focus and care we put into the things we do speaks volumes about what those things mean to us. 

3. YOUR EMOTIONS

The year was 1998 and my beloved Denver Broncos looked poised to put up the first 16-0 season in NFL history. Then, out of nowhere, the lowly New York Giants pulled off the upset and brought the winning streak to an end. 9 year old me was devastated. Tears began to well up in my eyes, at which point my mom offered a needed correction: “This isn’t worth crying over. It’s just a game.”

Maybe I can be given a pass for being so young at the time, but unfortunately the passion we have for sports can still come out even as adults. Every year videos go viral of somebody throwing their remote through the television in response to their team losing a big game.

While I’d venture to guess most Christian men don’t take it that far, it’s still considered fairly socially acceptable to spend the rest of the day in a bad mood when your team loses. 

Frankly, that is flat wrong. If a team full of men you don’t even know lose a game and it leads you to be short-tempered or sullen with your wife and kids, it’s a clear sign sports mean too much to you. If some friendly trash talk from a buddy leads you to snap back in anger, it should put some things in perspective.

It’s ok to care about the results, and caring means we’re going to end up disappointed pretty consistently. I watched those same Denver Broncos lose a Super Bowl by 5 touchdowns a few years ago, so believe me, I know. But there’s no asterisk in the Fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22-23) for “unless your team just suffered a painful defeat.”

Sadly, sports are one of the primary gods of choice in the world today. If you follow European soccer at all, you see just how easy it is for mankind to turn sports into a full-blown religion.

Church attendance is at an all-time low there, but every Saturday and Sunday the entire nation gets dressed in their “worship” garments, migrates to their “cathedral,” and spend two hours together belting out songs, chanting, and engaging in other time-honored rituals. They’re going to church and they don’t even realize it. 

It should serve as a cautionary tale for us, and a reminder that we are always worshiping someone or something. If it’s not God, it will be something like sports.

So, we must exercise caution and intentionality. Sports are one of many of life’s pleasures God has blessed us with, and, kept in moderation, we can find great joy and camaraderie in them. Let’s just be sure to keep those guardrails up to keep from bowing before them and expecting the kind of fulfillment that can only be found in our walk with God.

---

Notes:

New Cultural Breakdown coming Friday!

Last week I broke down Harrison Butker’s pro-motherhood speech that broke the internet. Unless any major headlines break, this week I plan to look at two Norman Rockwell paintings that say everything about how a society rises and collapses.

And, don’t forget the Little Free Library challenge we’re doing to stock community book boxes across the country with Sunday School Catch-Up! You can find most Little Free Libraries mapped out here.