The Weaponization of "Love Your Neighbor"

America's new favorite verse

It wasn’t all that long ago that Matthew 7:1 may have been the most-cited verse in the entire Bible. “Do not judge lest you be judged” was America’s new favorite Bible verse as many people, some of whom barely knew what a Psalm is, would pull out Jesus’ words on judgment any time they were told they were in the wrong.

The verse was ripped completely out of context, but that didn’t matter to those who used it that way. What mattered to them was that they had an easily remembered defense they felt could shut down anybody who opposed them.

“The Bible says ‘do not judge'” was the only phrase they needed to “win” a discussion and get people to do what they wanted – namely, to shut up and go away.

Over time, though, that verse got less and less use. I would venture to guess that it’s because many who “didn’t want to be judged” by hearing they were wrong have given up all pretense of caring what God says.

However, there’s a new verse being weaponized in conversation today.

That verse is known as the 2nd Greatest Commandment, tabbed as such by Jesus Himself in Matthew 22:39: “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.”

“Love your neighbor as yourself” is a vital, beautiful command from God’s Word. I have no intention of criticizing it or calling it unimportant. Just like “Do not judge,” though, “Love your neighbor” has been given a whole new meaning. It, too, is being cast by some as little more than a rhetorical tool for taking the upper hand in conversation.

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… which means you have to support socialism or you don’t love people.”

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… which means you have to wear a mask at all times (and/or get a shot) or you don’t love people.” (Boy, did 2020-2021 expose a lot of “loving” closet authoritarians.)

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… which means you have to endorse women preaching or you don’t love people.”

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… which means you must support LGBT causes or you don’t love people.”

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… which means you can’t object to 20,000 foreigners being dropped in your community.”

• “Love your neighbor as yourself… so stop being such a stickler for doctrine.”

To sum up: “If you really were a loving Christian, you would act and think exactly the way I do.”

Two major objections

First, it’s not enforceable

Sorry, no. All of these are matters of opinion at best. They do not have God’s authority behind them, and therefore it’s wrong to pretend they do. One can hold the opinion that these are the best ways to love one’s neighbor and that doing these things is the right way to carry out “love your neighbor as yourself.” But to imply or outright state that somebody is disobeying God because they don’t interpret the command the same way I do would be a sin.

Twisting a Bible verse to mean “You have to do exactly what I want you to” is a tactic that reeks of arrogance and selfishness. It is a worldly, ungodly tactic to emotionally manipulate a conversation and jockey for a perceived moral high ground to enact one’s will on others, and it’s downright shameful that some Christians would wield the same methods.

Loving brethren, acting in good faith, allow for differences of opinion and seek to understand each other. They refuse to browbeat their brothers and sisters to force conformity.

The irony is that in forcing everyone to think and act in accordance with one’s personal opinion is directly opposed to loving your neighbor as yourself. The Golden Rule (Matthew 7:12), the 2nd Greatest Commandment put into action, makes us consider how we would like to be treated.

None of us would like to be forced to comply with someone else’s opinions as a test of our walk with God. To do so is not to love one’s neighbor as one’s self. No, rather it is subjecting your neighbor to yourself.

Romans 14 gives us the framework for how we handle matters of opinion – even the one’s about which we feel really strongly. The principles given there are simple: don’t judge your brother for his opinion (14:3), don’t make your brother stumble (14:13), and, most importantly, pursue that which makes for peace and building each other up (14:19). Attempting to force brethren to hold our opinions violates all three of these.

Second, which neighbor?

Progressivism always picks the easy answer, totally oblivious to second-level effects. “Loving” 10 million immigrant neighbors seems like the easy choice… until you see that it can also hurt the citizenry. “Loving” the heretic by refusing to confront them seems like preserving unity… until you see how their false teaching harms the sheep. “Loving” LGBT people by accepting them seems like compassion… until you see how it affects everyone around to see God’s family be de-legitimized. (Not to mention the direct affects to the “loved” themselves, in each of these instances.)

We don’t live in a world of infinite truths or limitless resources. Costs exist, and pretending they aren’t real or refusing to count them isn’t loving. Indiscriminately throwing out “love your neighbor!” as a proclamation from a perceived moral high ground isn’t good enough. The homework has to be done.

The truth is, “Love your neighbor as yourself” is a difficult command. It means deferring to our neighbor (Romans 12:10, Philippians 2:3-4). It means training ourselves to see things from our neighbor’s perspective (Romans 14). It means loving each other even when it’s hard to like each other, especially when we disagree. If we’re using it as a weapon to grab an upper hand in an argument, we have missed the point entirely.

---

Notes

A brief note about subscriptions…

You may have noticed that, other than book giveaways, everything on this site is now FREE!

However, locking articles does drive more premium subscriptions, and the added income from those has been a tremendous boost to give my family a little more financial breathing room. In other words, giving everything away free does make it tougher to gain paying subscribers.

So, I want to thank all those who are premium subscribers for your invaluable support. And I want to encourage non-premium subscribers to consider upgrading. Having a steady growth of premium subscribers without using the paywall is a huge boost and helps me keep everything available free.

Thanks for subscribing, and for your consideration!