Aiming the wrong direction
Good way to put it. I usually categorize this sort of thing under “trying to be holier than Jesus”. Similar idea.
What is the Catholic church's track record of staying on track with the scripture?
Not great!
Just a thought, what is Christ’s position on capital punishment? After all, He’s an Expert on the Subject, and not just academically, but experientially, on the receiving end.
He’s quite clearly in favor of it, as it is endorsed in both Testaments.
Just curious, where in the NT?
Romans 13. Swords and vengeance.
Misapplication. The sword is what we all live under. We do not embrace it or live by it,—that is, if we’re actually Christians.
You and I don't wield it, but the government does. The text explicitly says they are God's avenger against evildoers.
This is the heart of the problem - people keep importing individual commands to discussions that are not about individuals at all.
Good way to put it. I usually categorize this sort of thing under “trying to be holier than Jesus”. Similar idea.
What is the Catholic church's track record of staying on track with the scripture?
Not great!
Just a thought, what is Christ’s position on capital punishment? After all, He’s an Expert on the Subject, and not just academically, but experientially, on the receiving end.
He’s quite clearly in favor of it, as it is endorsed in both Testaments.
Just curious, where in the NT?
Romans 13. Swords and vengeance.
Misapplication. The sword is what we all live under. We do not embrace it or live by it,—that is, if we’re actually Christians.
You and I don't wield it, but the government does. The text explicitly says they are God's avenger against evildoers.
This is the heart of the problem - people keep importing individual commands to discussions that are not about individuals at all.